1500 words-ish, probably somewhere around a ten minute read. Take the time and read the potentially life-saving info.

I’ve been around dog-internet for a really long time. I was around and first interacting with training/behaviour colleagues via LISTSERVE and Yahoo! Lists…yep, that long ago…

Back in those days, I truly believed that our collaborations online, via this new and developing social media, could change things. Really change things. Naively I, and many wonderful colleagues, really went to bat promoting reinforcement based approaches while lambasting aversive approaches; our main adversary at that time, was the emerging giant, Cesar Milan, and all he stood for.

There was backlash, and arguments, and it was so often heated. But all it served was to create more and more polarisation and the promotion of not-very-scientific arguing. I’m not proud of it, I recognise the good bits and the dogma. And I would probably do it differently if I had the chance for a do-over.

But despite all that, some of the worst backlash I have ever been on the receiving end of is when I have shared the most current, up-to-date, evidence-based information about first aid for HRI (heat related illness). Sheesh.

Actual lifesaving information about what to do in an emergency. And HRI is an emergency. We have minutes to make decisions, to do what needs to be done, and to get the dog to clinic.

Jump to:

• Heat Related Illness (HRI) details & overview
• Recognise when to take care!
• Stop the heating!
• This is an emergency!
• Share evidence based information.
• Get them Wet. Get them to the Vet.

What do you need to know?

Heat Related Illness (HRI), is a dangerous rise in body temperature that the body’s normal temperature regulating systems can’t accommodate. HRI leads to hyperthermia and thermal tissue damage. (Bouchama & Knochel 2002)

Less than half the dogs who develop severe HRI survive (Hall et al, 2021), but with early intervention lower case fatality rates have been recorded, e.g. 14% in Hall et al, 2020.

In dogs, HRI is most commonly caused by exertion in warm ambient temperatures. Contrary to popular belief, confinement in vehicles accounts for a relatively small proportion of HRI cases. (See Hall et al, 2020)

That’s not to suggest that you should confine dogs to a hot vehicle (!), but that the emphasis in popular media may cause bias. We must promote an understanding of the effects of exertion too. (See the Dogs Don’t Just Die in Hot Cars campaign)
Dogs taken from hot cars showing signs of HRI, were more likely to develop severe signs (Hall et al, 2022). Being left in hot car is very dangerous, but not the only risk we should emphasise!

The differences in successful outcomes is thought to be associated with getting help sooner. Usually, the dog has been left in the car alone so an owner may not get back to them until HRI has progressed, while humans may be able to get help quicker when out with their dogs exercising (Hall et al, 2022). The bottom line is that more dogs die from HRI after exertion (Hall et al, 2020).

In London, dogs were found to be more likely to be confined to hot buildings and Hall et al, 2022, showed that the number of HRI cases relating to hot-building confinement was doubled there. This is likely replicated in other urbanised environments particularly due to the way concrete structures & distribution of buildings hold heat along with a lack of trees, or places where dogs are confined indoors in warm places for long periods, during mild and warm weather.

Recognise when to take care!

This dog, in this clip, shows excessive panting. Note their posture, raised head, extended tongue and the panting – this posture and panting shows the body trying to get more air. Stop the heating!

First aid now!

Clip link

Dogs don’t regulate their behaviour well when stressed and wound up, which may include excitement and exertion. This means they will continue to go-go-go even when uncomfortably hot or in pain.

It’s important to note that exertion related heat distress occurs all year round, while confinement in vehicles accounts for cases in the Spring/Summer mainly. (The Hall et al, works are based in the UK, so you would imagine similar weather/conditions in Ireland.)

Hall et al, 2022, found that the maximum ambient temperature on days with HRI reports was just 16.9C (about 62F). This shows that we must monitor our dogs’ exertion and thermal comfort, even on mild days.
There was even one case of exertional HRI recorded on a 3.3C day!

And it gets interesting when we consider how dogs in hotter climates fare. Bruchim et al, 2008, looked at cases of HRI in Israel. They found that about 85% of dogs presenting at the veterinary hospital had developed HRI signs on 24C days.

‘Heat waves’ may be particularly risky as dogs will take about 4-6 weeks to acclimate to changes in temperature.

And how ambient temperature is measured, recorded and reported may also mislead. For example, weather station temperature, often what’s reported on the news, will be taken in the shade. Your dog playing in your garden in the sun may experience much greater temperatures.

With increases in the use of artificial grass, especially in homes with pets, there are plenty of reports of how hot that surface becomes. If you are taking care with the temperature of pavements your dog walks on, consider also the surfaces at home.

Stop the heating!

Our tendency is to think of cooling, and most dangerously, gradual cooling for dogs with HRI. Instead, let’s start thinking in terms of stopping the heating first.

Contrary to popular belief, dogs do sweat but their main form of cooling, at higher ambient temperatures, is panting, and this puts strain on the body and produces heat. (How do dogs regulate their body temperature? from Dr Marlin)

There really is little evidence to suggest that using cold or ice water slows cooling. While ice water may cause vasoconstriction (narrowing of blood vessels), this is unlikely to have an impact on cooling when the dog is overheating, as they are not using radiation of heat, from the skin, to cool the body efficiently.

Cold tap water (under ~15C), poured over the dog likely provides efficient cooling, based on the limited evidence from research (Magazanik et al, 1980). Although much colder water was shown to be similarly effective, in an emergency situation, it’s probably going to be more efficient to find tap water; this is urgent so we don’t want people going to the trouble of finding icy water!

Move the dog to a cooler area and place them on wet towels. Thoroughly wet their coat with water cooler than their body and initially cool them quickly.

Evidence based measures, from Dr Marlin, discussed here.

This is an EMERGENCY! Act accordingly.

What’s most important, is that cooling measures (or, stopping the heating measures) are in place as quickly as possible and those measures stop body temperature increases and drop body temperature fast. Drobatz & Macintire 1996, found that, without cooling measures before getting to the vet, almost half of the dogs with HRI died. And this risk more than halved where cooling measures were implemented earlier.

Cooling measures should be applied even as you travel to the vet. Remember that the back of the car is usually a good deal hotter than the front seats so ventilate well.

Brachycephalic dogs are more likely to die from HRI but are not more likely to develop severe disease. Hall et al, 2022, suggests that these dogs are at greater risk of respiratory failure earlier. That’s why treating even early signs FAST is so important, especially in dogs with underlying conditions such as respiratory issues.

HRI can lead to longer term complications; even if cooling measures are successful at the scene and the dog appears recovered – they must see a vet and quick.

Review and Share Evidence Based Information:

• Dr David Marlin is an excellent source and active, with lots of resources, on socials.
• Canine Heat Injury Prevention & Field Treatment Facebook page is an excellent source of evidence based and practical information.
• Heatstroke.dog
• Veterinary Voices UK
• The Veterinary Tactical Group are conducting ongoing data collection and research in this area.

Get them wet. Get them to the vet.

This is truly life-saving information. And evidence-based:

• Bradbury, et al. 2023
• Carter, et al. 2024
• Beard, et al. 2022
• Davis, et al.2019

You can wet the dog, right down to their skin, with cold water and you won’t cause “shock”. Keep wetting them.
Don’t cover them up. Don’t think that just wetting limited body areas will be sufficient. It won’t.

Indeed cold water immersion can be more effective. But is not safe for unconscious dogs, weak dogs, or dogs that may be difficult to manage for the first-aider. That’s why I promote getting them wet, down to the skin. And getting them to the vet, even if they seem recovered and well.

Decker at about 6 weeks and then at just under 6 months:

In what seems like only minutes, your butter-wouldn’t-melt puppy turns into a lanky, boisterous teenager.

Puppies are adorable and goofy, bringing joy and smiles to even the grumpiest faces. And while new puppy people often lament at the difficulties of puppy rearing, those are nothing compared to the drama that comes with canine adolescence.

Teenage dogs are the most at risk of becoming unwanted; Irish pounds and rescue organisations are filled with adolescent dogs needing homes and help. Adolescence is hard for adolescents and their humans.  

Take it one or two sections at a time:

• What is canine adolescence?
• When is canine adolescence?
• Your dog’s brain on adolescence
• REFRAME!
• Guardians of adolescent dogs need support too
• The need for healthy relationships
• Adolescent dogs are vulnerable
• Preparing for adolescence starts with puppies
• Growing Pains
• Surviving Canine Adolescence
• What they don’t need…
• Dogs don’t grow out of behaviour ‘problems’, they just grow into them

What is canine adolescence?

Adolescence is a distinct developmental period during which puppies become adult dogs. Adolescent dogs experience much of the same adolescent-phase changes that teenage children experience.

When we think of typical teenage-antics, we might recognise:

• increased risk taking
• increased emotional sensitivity
• increased social motivation
• decreased behavioural inhibition
• increased conflicts with care-givers

(Asher, et al, 2020)

We’ve all been there…

Adolescence is a time of change

• physical, endocrinological, neurological
• behavioural
• sexual & reproductive behaviours
• social roles & behaviour

The guardians of teenage dogs also experience changes in response to their dogs’ development.
Behaviours once considered naughty or entertaining in puppies are now considered deliberate & defiant. Their puppy has shed much of their “cute” infantile features and now humans have much higher expectations of their adolescent.

(Owczarczak-Garstecka, et al, 2023)

Teenage dogs are a work in progress with a brain under construction. They are not ready for adulthood or adult expectations.

When is canine adolescence?

Although there will be individual differences, adolescence begins around the time they get their adult teeth and begins to level off as they approach social and behavioural maturity between 2.5 and 3 years.

(Harvey 2021)

Your dog’s brain on adolescence

Teenagers have to progress from baby helplessness toward adult independence and to do that their brains and bodies need to go through a lot of change.
They have to become more independent, be able to make decisions and think about which information to apply to different situations – adults have to do things that are basically the opposite to puppies!

With body growth almost done, there are resources freed up for brain development and for behaviour to test it all out in their world.

(Casey et al, 2010) (Larsen & Luna 2018) (Spear 2013) (Steinberg, et al, 2017)

During this stage the brain is gradually becoming a better thinking, decision-making organ but while this is happening it doesn’t function very well as a thinking, decision-making organ at all.

Parts of the brain that look after learning, concentration and impulsivity are busily being built rather than helping the teenager with coping with stress and recovery. And just like when a motorway is being remodeled there are diversions; information and messages in the teenage brain are diverted, to more reactionary areas, while the brain is getting its make over. This often results in over-the-top reactions and slow recoveries (we’ve all been through it so this should be no surprise).

Along with brain re-modelling, the teenager’s body is bathed in changes and swings in hormonal shifts preparing their bodies for social contest, reproduction and parenthood.

All the while, the teenager is getting their adult teeth and their adult bodies, grappling with these changes and learning how to put their new body to good use.

With their bigger, bolder and stronger bodies, changing brains and responding, adolescent behaviour may come as a surprise. But really, quite a lot of it is due to them clearer, better at communicating more obviously, and being bigger and stronger.

What happens to a dog in their first year of life is most impactful on their adult behaviour and behavioural health (Foyer et al, 2014). While we now give lots of attention to puppy-training, once puppies hit adolescence, we often wash our hands of those puppy-protocols and send the teenager off to obedience-and-manners land.

Adolescent dogs need careful guidance and their developing behaviour requires nurturing. Adolescence is a time of change & challenge for teenagers and their carers.

REFRAME!

Understanding your teenager helps you reframe their behaviour and appreciate what they can, and can’t do!

It may or may not be of great comfort to hear that your adolescent dog’s behaviour is outside their control, and likely a normal part of their being a teenager. But there is hope and there are plenty of things we can do to help our dogs. And for the rest, we just need to survive it!

Adolescent dogs need understanding, more support, more patience and some time. Same for their guardians!

Teenagers need our help…they just have a goofy way of asking for it sometimes! Your dog’s behaviour is information & we just need to learn the best ways to respond.

Don’t give up hope, get help!

Guardians of adolescent dogs need support too

It can feel very lonely to live with a teenager, and guardians might feel blamed for their dog’s behaviour. Preparing guardians for what they can expect as their dog develops from puppy to adolescent can help with improving outcomes for both ends of the lead.

(Duxbury et al 2003) (Gazzano et al, 2008)

As puppies grow into their new bodies, they lose a lot of that typical puppy cuteness. This changes their guardians’ attitudes toward them and along with the passing of time, guardians will expect their lanky teenagers to behave more like adult dogs.
Human perceived ‘cuteness’ is important in predicting the quality of human-canine relationships.

(Owczarczak-Garstecka, et al, 2023) (Thorn et al, 2015)

Guardian perceptions of their dogs’ behaviour change as their dog ages, with very different expectations of puppies versus teenage dogs.

Remember, adolescent dogs are a work in progress with a brain under construction.

The need for healthy relationships

It is well recognised that relationships between teenagers & their care-givers can be strained. (We’ve all been there!) There appears to be analogous effects affecting human-canine teenager relationships too.

(Asher, et al, 2020)

While we should recognise that our relationships with our adolescent dogs will be strained for some time, we can also focus on relationship building to develop healthy, secure attachment relationships. The payoff comes a few months down the line but this is a priceless investment.

Adolescent education emphasises protecting our teenagers from unhealthy stress & building healthy relationships.

Guardians of adolescent dogs are often blamed & feel judged for their dogs’ behaviour. There is no place for blaming & shaming.

Be empowered by the understanding that you can make appropriate adjustments to your teenager’s environmental conditions, supporting healthier behaviour and & behavioural development.

Find the right professional to help you & provide you with appropriate evidence-based explanations for your dog’s behaviour.

Teenage dogs are vulnerable, and so are their guardians. Get help to keep your dog safe & with you.

Adolescent dogs are vulnerable

Adolescent dogs can’t win. Their adolescent behaviour, over which they have no control, gets them killed because they live in an incompatible human world.

Teenage dogs are a work in progress. They are trying to navigate the complex & (relatively) under-enriched human world with a brain under-construction and in a social environment holding unrealistic expectations against them.

We, as humans with all the control, can learn to support teenage dogs, setting them up for success & ensuring a safe place for them in our human world. But we have to do the work.

Your adolescent dog is not trying to give you a hard time, they’re having a hard time!

Not only is adolescence wreaking havoc with their brains & bodies, but their behaviour puts them at increased risk too.

• adolescent dogs are most at risk of becoming unwanted & relinquishment
• dogs under the age of three are more likely to die due to behavioural euthanasia

Given their brain is under construction & particularly sensitive to stress, further exposure to stress may be more impactful, potentially contributing to the development of trauma/ trauma-like responses.

(Corridan et al, 2024) (Pegram et al, 2021) (Powell et al 2021) (Salman et al, 2000) (Talamonti et al, 2018) (Weiss et al, 2014)

Preparing for adolescence starts with puppies

We can begin to help our dogs prepare for adolescence when they are still puppies, just by having a little awareness of what’s about to happen in the coming months. And we can help puppy people prepare before their dog hits adolescence too!

Puppies appear more tolerant than they often are. Their communication and behavioural systems are not mature and we can find it trickier to interpret their responses. That can lead us to put puppies in some unsuitable situations…we do lots of stuff to puppies that we just don’t do to adult dogs as they wouldn’t be appear so tolerant.

You can imagine the associations puppies are making during this impressionable time. As they move into and through adolescence, they become better at saying NO! or WAIT!, or more so, we become better at recognising their objections. We think they have become more difficult, but they may just have had enough, and now they can let us know more obviously.

Of course, not everybody gets to meet their dog as a puppy, and sometimes, we are jumping right in during adolescence.

While we might have a little idea of what’s going on inside their brains and bodies, it’s their behaviour that is information for us. We can apply that information to ensuring we are meeting the needs of the individual teenager today, & into the future.

There is a tendency to dust off our hands and draw a line under puppy training, moving onto adolescent education as if it were a different entity altogether. Teenagers require just as much specialised support as puppies and their humans even more so.

Adolescent programs should be a natural continuation of enrichment-based puppy programs, which are dog-led. Certainly, that’s the way we do it!

Growing Pains

The perfect puppyhood honeymoon is over…adolescence has hit and teenage behaviours are rearing their ugly heads.

Adolescence brings an increase in activity, strength, fitness, vocalisation, swings in responses, destruction, spookiness, aggressive responding, distress, humping, distraction, toileting & marking, difficulty with calming and interest in the opposite sex.

Sounds like fun, right?

Surviving Canine Adolescence

Having a good start with puppy training and appropriate social and environmental exposure certainly helps, but for the most part, adolescence brings challenge.

Manage to prevent adolescent behaviours sticking: although teenage behaviours relate to transient changes, they can stick particularly when accompanied by a rich reinforcement history.

Management means we set our adolescent up for success by preventing them being put in situations where they may carry out unwanted behaviours. Pros, this requires skilled antecedent arrangement.

Continue with appropriate social and environmental exposure: teenagers are probably more likely to appear to over-react when experiencing emotional swings, which are just more dramatic during adolescence.

Make sure teenagers get lots of space from stress-cues, have options for how they engage in social interactions, and continue to pair good things with exposure to social and environmental stimuli.

Supervision and observation: although most associated with puppy training, supervising of the teenager is useful too to stop destruction, humping and leg lifting before it happens, by redirecting the teenager to other more appropriate outlets.

Close supervision of dog-dog interactions is especially important, particularly where a number of teenagers hang out together.

Teach them to be good human trainers: teenagers tend to have trouble with waiting their turn, calming themselves after getting wound up and engaging with their people in the midst of distractions.

Teach teenagers how to train humans to get the things they want to help them to choose their human over the goings-on. This is more about you becoming easy to train!

Physical and Mental Exercise: teenagers are stronger and more active than puppies, all of a sudden. They will need increased physical and mental exercise, while carefully helping them avoid frustration and recover from getting wound up.

Improve the value of rewards: puppies bask in their owner’s love but it’s not so cool to be seen with your parents when you’re a teenager.

Building motivation for interaction with you, choosing you, and for play and fun with their person certainly goes a long way to boosting engagement.

Remember, rewards are things the dog chooses – what is the dog already doing? That can often give you information about the things that your dog likes to do. Making sure they get to do these activities is important, just as participating with them, keeping it fun and helping them choose engagement.

Clarity and Consistency: more than at any life stage teenagers need to be able to predict what’s going to happen to them. This is largely about you being consistent and clear in all interactions with them.
While management to prevent unwanted behaviour is important, rewarding desirable behaviour is essential too.

Take responsibility for your dog’s behaviour and set them up for success .

Accepting responsibility: the ‘Teenager’ label is used to get guardians out of all sorts of trouble but the human end of the leash must take on the challenges of living with and supporting an adolescent.
Humans tend to hold the teenager more accountable for their behaviour; they are not so cute anymore and “should know better”.
The popular opinion that teenagers are stubborn and belligerent is flawed; teenagers can’t know or do better; some days their brains are not going to be working quite right and on most days, teenagers, as opposed to puppies, will not put up with mixed signals from their teachers.

What they don’t need…

More wild & crazy is probably not helpful

The temptation is to try to tire the teenager, to run them, to have them engage in high-octane activities like group dog-dog play or repetitive fetch games.

Dog parks, daycares and play groups may not be the best place for adolescent dogs to develop appropriate social skills, and may cause teenagers to associate high arousal with other dogs and the related excitement. (HINT: they probably already associate being wound up in these contexts…)

Regular repetitive exerting activities are also likely to lead to increasing arousal, difficulty with calming and becoming harder to live with.

Appropriate social and environmental exposure, along with suitable mental and physical exercise, are the keys to helping you and your dog through adolescence. Get help, get committed and remember that your teenage dog is not trying to give you a hard time, they are having a hard time.

“Frustration tolerance” and “impulse control” training may be misplaced

The teenage brain is poorly equipped to tolerate frustration or exert “impulse” control. Why then, do so many training programs emphasise such poorly defined fuzzy concepts?

Our dogs’ behaviour tells us what they are ready for and what they are not quite able for just yet. Program design should set learners up for success by listening to what their behaviour is telling us.

Adolescent development tells us that they need appropriate cognitive challenge, without frustration, opportunities to move, lots of exploration & building independence. And we must learn to keep them safe & manage their world carefully.

Dogs don’t grow out of behaviour ‘problems’, they just grow into them

Teenage behaviours don’t stop just because your dog matures and ages. If anything, these sometimes worrisome behaviours just become more established and honed, and more serious and adult-like.

Behaviour happens in the environment, even when related to brain or hormonal changes, so the adolescent’s environment requires adjustment and ongoing, responsive adjustment throughout development.

We can make the right changes to support adolescent dogs, with the right education and understanding!

Remember, your adolescent dog is having a hard time rather than trying to give you a hard time. But this is your time to step up, keep supporting your teenager, and helping them develop coping skills for adult life.

Jump to:

• Go Find It! game
• Why the Go Find It! game?

Go Find It! game

I will introduce the Go Find It! game for almost all dogs because it’s so beneficial and versatile.
This game teaches the dog to engage with their human to search the floor or grass, or where ever, for tossed food rewards or other rewards such as a toy.

Clip link

We don’t have to teach dogs how to sniff, they got that down. But we can teach them to search on cue (to a verbal signal, “Go Find It!”) so that we can encourage them to sniff at particular times and in certain situations.

Because dogs don’t actually understand words, and we often think they are understanding our cues when they are usually not, we have to teach signals in a certain way.
This clip shows the mechanics of teaching the Go Find It! cue:

The important bit is to say the verbal cue, “Go Find It!” before even thinking about reaching for the food you will toss. Your dog can’t learn about verbal cues if there is even a hint the food is coming, so we keep them separate with just a beat in-between.

With practice, you can build a whiplash turn in response to this cue to prevent pulling on leash, getting over-excited or distracted, like Bella in this clip:

Practicing in the relevant contexts, such as out on a walk, but with very low levels of distractions, can be more effective than practicing at home alone (but do that too!).

Why “Go Find It!”?

• a fun searching game that dogs love

Clip link

• to release your dog to go be a dog

Clip link

• provide more calming outlets

Clip link

• a diversion if you’re busy or occupied

Clip link

• preventing and redirecting from unwanted behaviours

Clip link

• redirect excitement

Clip link

• use to reward engagement (e.g. focus on you, walking close to you)

Clip link

• helping your dog wind down and relax after excitement or exertion

Clip link

• providing a diversion from something approaching that might bother or distract your dog

Clip link

• familiarise and gradually build comfort in new environments

Clip

• comfortably move away from potential stressors

Clip link

• helping to create pleasant associations and comfort with general and specific situations

Clip

It’s so versatile though that we can adapt this game to help your dog and to provide them with lots and lots of sniffing opportunities.

I teach and work on this game so much I could add many more clips and examples of its application…perhaps a part 2 is in the works…

Just over 1100 words and about 6-ish minutes read time for this one.

9th December marks the International Day of Veterinary Medicine, recognising the vital contributions that vets, and support staff including RVNs (a valuable profession in and of its own rite), make to animal health & welfare, public health, food safety, policy development and their roles in One Health One Welfare applications.

My favourite cases are those where we get to collaborate and create a care-team for the dog, working alongside allied professionals including the dog’s vet-team. I am so lucky to get to work with some wonderful vets, alongside my clients, creating dream-teams to help pets and their people.

On social media, I regularly, and most recently, see references to “pain trials” and how ‘pet owners’ will need to accept that this isn’t a quick-fix scenario. While I agree that trial analgesia can be lengthy, costly and even overwhelming, it’s up to behaviour professionals to ensure that we are communicating with both our clients and vets, supervising the behavioural aspects appropriately, and collecting and presenting data suitable to both clients and vets to ensure progress can be made.

The buck stops with us.

If the end user/s, clients and vets, are having difficulty with our interventions, rather than targeting external accountability, start within. What can we do better?

A boy who cries pain

It certainly is easier now, more than ever before in my career, to discuss the relationships between physical health, disorder and behaviour. High rates of occurrence of physical contributions are often cited as relating to behaviours of concern, across research, e.g., Mills et al, 2020, and anecdotally from professionals (e.g., in 2024 ~60% of AniEd cases included physical contributors).

While improved recognition is good, there are still gaps in our knowledge, and in the procedures we apply to communicate the relationships between pain and behaviour.

It’s not enough for behaviour professionals to declare that an animal is “in pain”, or lament that the vet just needs to prescribe and get on board. Pain is a multi-dimensional, subjective experience (Wiech et al, 2008). that we can’t rule out on behalf of another individual. It is not easily detectable during visits to the veterinary clinic and diagnostics, like x-rays, can’t provide definitive answers either.

But, fear not! Behaviour is our super-power (in more ways than one!). Behaviour can and should be considered part of clinical signs to inform diagnoses and treatments (Dinwoodie et al, 2021). And we can act as translators between clients & their dogs and the vet-team.

We must be specific and clear. We cannot expect guardians and carers to observe and interpret their dogs’ behaviour – they often do not have the skills for such specific observations, and, it’s incredibly difficult to be objective about your own loved ones.

We must collect information via questionnaire and interview techniques, we must make direct and indirect observations of the dog’s behaviours, and we must support our clients in collecting ongoing data (there will be spreadsheets!). We take this from our clients and translate that into appropriate terms for the dog’s vet-team. No vague statements or euphemisms – actual observable behaviours and evidence-based language that can relate to diagnostic and treatment approaches.

Only the vet can decide on medications, treatment options and diagnostics. But that doesn’t exclude or devalue our contributions, it’s a collaboration!

Behaviour is still in the environment

With our increased awareness and willingness to discuss the bidirectional relationships between physical and behavioural health, it’s everywhere. But as with anything that may be treated as social media fodder, extremes and polarisation are rampant. Pathologising behaviour is widespread as we become convinced by current trends and blinded to the nuances of behaviour.

Of course this infects our insistence about client or veterinary attitudes to our efforts – they are mistaken, their expectations are unreasonable, them, them, them…

Trial analgesia isn’t some panacea. Behaviour is still in the environment. The painful dog’s distance increasing response, e.g., growling and snapping, is still negatively reinforced when the hand reaching for them withdraws. And that response can be maintained beyond our analgesia efforts.

Trial analgesia is just one piece of the puzzle

There are many different types of pain and many types of pain relief. History, data collection and observations may provide some insight into the types of pain potentially contributing to behaviour. Also, it might not.

We can’t just throw things at the wall, hoping something sticks. We form hypotheses using observable behavioural data and our efforts must be falsifiable. Collecting the right data allows us to determine if trial analgesia is appropriate, and, when and what adjustments may be trialed next.

Expectations must be realigned with reality and a roadmap produced for both client and vet-team so we are all on the same journey together. Both need to understand observations that indicate we’re on the right track, and when we’re not…and what that might mean for our plan.
In this collaboration, we are constructing just a fraction of the plan: the clients contributes their bit, the vet-team their bits and the dog must have a say too!

Trial analgesia should be at least 4 weeks, but for clearer data collection, up to 8-12 weeks can be better (Mills et al, 2020). We are not expecting some magical turnaround…remember, behaviour is still in the environment. And we might continue to trial and collect data, or, we might pivot and look at alternative analgesia with continued data collection. We are supervising and supporting along the way (so many shared spreadsheets!).

Given that chronic pain is a chronic stressor, it makes sense that anxiolytic medications may also be indicated (Mills et al, 2020) and may support increased plasticity, helping the brain heal, recover and adapt (Jetsonen, et al, 2025).

Starting both at the same time is sometimes required to improve welfare, but can muddy the waters in our data collection. However, effects can be distinguished at a later time when we have progressed through our intervention plan a little.

Pain relief is not just about pain relief! Pain is multi-systemic affecting behaviour, cognition, inflammation, activity and social interactions. And that means multi-modal pain relief as part of our intervention programs.

Nuance

At AniEd, our professionals and learners do courses and CPD on behaviour health as health, communicating and collaborating with veterinary and allied professionals, and on supervising, guiding and supporting clients in data collection. This is no time for superficial or tenuous recommendations.

I’m not suggesting that awareness of a need for treatment of pain, and other physical contributors to behaviour, should be downplayed. Nope, we have fought hard to build this recognition and we continue to do so.

There must be balance and consideration for how we communicate, supervise and support these investigations as collaborations, as part of team building…building that dream-team.

I don’t often praise social media, particularly in relation to the dog world and dog welfare, but one thing it provides us with is insight into the culture, particularly directed toward dogs, of various dog businesses, pages, organisations and individuals.

That is, these insights, usually videos and posts, provide so much excellent content for learning about canine behaviour, the language we use to discuss behaviour, and often, how not to do those things. But most of all, social media provides us with insight into the understanding, the awareness, the skills & the knowledge of those posting.

Yes, I’m a lurker and a spy. But I claim usage for educational purposes…

Experienced dog professionals, and those who represent themselves in a position of expertise (which on social media doesn’t mean a lot, much of the time), should be a buffer for the quality of the information they produce or share. Maybe someone has shared a clip with them but when they share inappropriate interactions, stressed dogs (without recognising it) or potentially harmful demonstrations, it’s apparent that they may not have a wonderful foundation in understanding canine behaviour.

I have higher expectations of, and hold them to a higher account, these social media content-producers, influencers, experts (or however they rank themselves). Those professionalising dog care, taking fees and charging guardians, those responsible for enforcing dog control legislation, those who care for vulnerable dogs and those advising guardians on “responsible dog ownership” must be unimpeachable in their knowledge and skill regarding canine behaviour, welfare, handling and care.

But our education on canine behaviour is not standardised and without accountability. And that means despite someone’s title, social media hype and postnominals, we might not be able to expect a whole lot.

Often through social media, or, at least facilitated by social media, professionals are drawn to the latest and greatest. I note who is reaching for the fads, noting that foundations in knowledge and skill must be lacking such is their vulnerability to the marketing and the hype.

Maslow’s hammer

The outcome of our interactions with dogs are a result of environmental conditions. This is a fundamental understanding of animal behaviour – behaviour is not in the individual, it’s in the environment. And as humans, we are largely responsible for the environmental conditions to which dogs are exposed.

During this past week, International Day for the Elimination of Violence Against Women was marked. I can’t help relating any of the world’s goings-on to dogs, and our relationships with dogs. Dogs and humans are joined, intertwined, and separation and separate considerations are not possible.

Misogyny and machismo, and their impacts on violence, can be felt throughout dog training, behaviour & care. Our fields of work and study have not escaped violence, aggression, and cruelty inflicted on dogs in the name of “training”, “welfare” and “safety”.

The direct examples, of course, include deliberate abuse and violence suffered by dogs in homes and families affected by domestic violence, and the focus on companion dogs, and other companion animals, as tools for coercive control.

But our industry has been and continues to be shaped by tools and techniques, attitudes and advice, that presents violence, aggression and cruelty as a means, and first line option, for maintaining safety of humans. And that very idea of safety is weaponised against dogs who are victims of their circumstances.

As someone who works with dogs under stress, whose behaviour can pose serious safety risk to humans, and sometimes where there is urgent pressure to clear the way safely, I acknowledge that from time to time, direct action is required.

But, when all you have is a hammer, everything looks like a nail. When the foundation understanding of behaviour is incomplete, partially constructed, or lacking, it’s easier for these direct actions, most often acts of violence and aggression against dogs, to be implemented.

If this, a basis in coercion and suppression, is central to the education of professionals then it all too easily becomes normalised and accepted. Even more.

When I see professionals, on whom I have been spying via their socials, demonstrate lacking in these areas and a focus on education in those areas, I am very concerned that some of our most vulnerable dogs will suffer. And people won’t be any safer.
But machismo will have won again, begetting more violence, perpetuating more aggression, creating more macho-men who blame dogs, label dogs, persecute dogs.

What we do to dogs.